Feature GB196: Is there a male/female distinction in 2nd person independent pronouns?

Patrons: Hannah J. Haynie

Description

Summary

This feature asks whether the phonologically independent pronoun forms used for second persons differ for masculine and feminine referents. This masculine/feminine distinction is a minimal contrast required for the coding of this feature, but other gender categories may also be encoded in second person pronoun forms. Pronoun systems that encode other grammatical gender/noun class categories in second person forms in the absence of a masculine/feminine distinction are not sufficient to satisfy this criterion. Languages that qualify for a 1 code for this feature will include a distinction between masculine and feminine forms in at least some categories of second person independent pronouns, but possibly not all categories. In many languages this contrast occurs only in the singular pronouns; that is, there is a contrast between masculine and feminine forms for second person singular, but not for second person plural (or dual, or any other non-singular number category). In some languages there is a contrast in multiple number categories, including singular and some non-singular number categories. It is uncommon for a language to have a masculine/feminine contrast in non-singular second person pronouns but not in the singular pronouns. However such languages would also satisfy the criteria for this feature. For more information on the difference between grammatical gender and social, cultural, and biological constructs or traits, see the gender wiki page.

Procedure

  1. If the language has second person independent pronouns that take a different form depending on whether the referent is masculine or feminine, code 1.
  2. If the language has second person independent pronouns that do not contrast in gender, code 0.
  3. If the language has second person independent pronouns that do not encode a masculine/feminine gender contrast, but do encode some other distinctions in gender, code ? and provide a comment about the contrast that is encoded in these pronouns.

Examples

Standard Arabic (ISO 639-3: arb, Glottolog: stan1318)

Arabic independent pronouns include masculine and feminine forms for the second person singular and plural.

Second person independent personal pronouns

Gender Singular Dual Plural
masculine 'anta 'antum
feminine 'anti 'antunna
non-specific 'antumaa

(Ryding 2005: 298)

Although there is only one second person dual personal pronoun which can be interpreted as either masculine or feminine, the presence of a masculine/feminine distinction in the singular and plural forms is sufficient to trigger a 1 for this feature for Standard Arabic.

Wandala (ISO 639-3: mfi, Glottolog: wand1278)

Wandala’s independent pronoun system encodes three person categories, two number categories, and an inclusive/exclusive distinction in first person pronouns, but no gender categories for any person or number category.

Wandala independent pronouns

Person Singular Plural
1 íyyà míyà (INCL)
ŋrè (EXCL)
2 ə̀kká kùré
3 ŋánè ítàrè or ítèrè

(Frajzyngier 2012: 107)

Wandala has no gender contrast in second person independent pronouns, so it is coded 0.

Further reading

Siewierska, Anna. 2005. Gender distinctions in independent personal pronouns. In Haspelmath, Martin, Matthew S. Dryer, David Gil, and Bernard Comrie (eds.) The World Atlas of Language Structures, 182–185. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

References

Frajzyngier, Zygmunt. 2012. A grammar of Wandala. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.

Ryding, Karin C. 2005. A reference grammar of modern standard Arabic. New York: Cambridge University Press.


To display the datapoints for a particular language family on the map and on the classification tree, select the family then click "submit".

You may combine this variable with a different variable by selecting on in the list below and clicking "Submit".

Customize map markers:
0 absent 2051
1 present 117
? Not known 47
reload

Map


Values

Name Glottocode Family Macroarea Contributor Value Source Comment